Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That's what Steve Jobs said. He can be wrong.


Dropbox should've been a feature of the operating system, but it isn't, because OS vendors have convinced themselves there's nothing left to do since the Internet is just going to solve all the hard problems now.

Seriously, I rue the day someone decided not to build-in such features as Internet-wide file sharing into my operating system, giving me full control over my content - subjugating me, instead, to the whims of yet another un-trustable third party.


Dropbox is a company that hosts your files.

If it was a feature of the operating system, who would host the files?


There are no good reasons I couldn't host my own files, with my own bandwidth, on my perfectly cromulant server/mobile device.

The only issue is, it hasn't been considered of any importance to maintain user agency; better we steal the users agency over their data/computers, put it out 'in the cloud', and get them addicted/dependent on third parties, than to make the operating system deliver similar levels of service, at scale, at the local level.

What if, instead of getting all hot and bothered about browsers, OS-teams instead focused on making source-/locality-/ownership- of user-generated data, within the context of the local machine, available at scale?

Like, gimme IPFS open and operating by default, in my regular distro, and I'll never have to host a site on a cloud server again...

Todays computers/bandwidth/connectivity can handle the load.


No, they can't.

Also, the battery can't handle your laptop open 24/7 just to serve a couple of files you _might_ need someday in your phone or other computer.


My systems can certainly handle the load I would impose upon them by sharing content to my personal social network.

What they can't handle is the load imposed on them by the farming of data by third-parties from my feed. But thats okay - because thats exactly what I want to get rid of.


Microsoft, Apple and Google (among others) all offer cloud-based hosting.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: