Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

OP meant searchable public group. In discord you need an invite link, and there's no way to search by its name.


Discord recently added a "Server Discovery" feature[0]. It's limited to verified servers though, which should mitigate the problems Kik had.

[0]: https://support.discordapp.com/hc/en-us/articles/36003084333...


But I believe you can search for subreddits as well? The same is true on BAND with searchable, public, joinable communities.


Instant messaging (Kik, Discord, Slack) has totally different uses cases than Reddit, which is more like a forum.


some groups will auto-kick inactive users. or require manual approval to join . that makes them a different use case than subreddits


so exactly like irc only not irc, which makes it better because, um..?


Searchable (history) and notifiable. Really that's all IRC would need right now to catch up. And a dead simple app, kik was actually pretty close, groups were even named #groups. All other features are gimmicks.


[flagged]


I'm not sure that response is as helpful as you think it is. I'm pretty sure irc has searchable public groups fwiw. Pretty sure irc is text based group chat.

If there's something that kik gets you beyond irc it's completely unclear from this discussion what that might be. Whether or not I'm delusional, and I sure I am as delusional as anyone about certain things, your response isn't useful, informative, helpful or kind. But YMMV.


I mean, they had a shiny app, marketing, and I'd guess similar features the young target group appreciated. A lot of things are like IRC but preferred by the new generation. People don't often select apps based on their backend stack.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: