Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

When one goal post is meet, you move the goal posts, sneaky and dishonest. I was answering a comment that specifically said:

> And what, may I ask, are your pea shooters going to do against the firepower of a corrupt nation state?

I think my comment quite clearly answered this question.

> bravery alone does not stop armies and did not stopped the armies. Power

Like the POWER AND BRAVERY of the ARMED local militias in the US which HELPED drive out the world's most powerful army. I'm sure glad they didn't get disarmed. Notice though, I said help. I'll admit my wording in regards to Russia was poor.

All or nothing arguments that remove the nuance (like saying 'it does' or 'it doesn't') are generally employed by people who aren't well positioned to understanding the complexities of reality. Any intelligent review includes more nuanced words. And any review that completely dismisses the power of armed local populations resisting oppression is simply going to be detached from reality and history. The use of the derogatory term 'pea shooter' is the perfect example of this dismissive, arrogant and ignorant take on history.

The Nazis my grandfather killed by putting lead through their skull certainly didn't think those were 'pea shooters', it takes a certain type of keyboard warrior to see a gun that way. Even a little .22 purse gun is no trivial matter.

> The argument is about whether it can protect the freedom

The people my grandfather saved I'm pretty would agreed that they 'obtained freedom/had their freedom protected thanks in great measure to the small arms' my grandfather had. Which kinda covers both the original goal posts and the new ones you created.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: