Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I wish there was something better than Elastic for indexing large volume of text.


Apache Solr?

Maybe not "better", but useful and with a Apache 2.0 license :)




That’s absolutely not the right tool for indexing large volumes of text. It’s a time series database with very rudimentary labelling support.


This is a better alternative to ES strictly for log analysis application. Not for search.


Yes.

AWS should build a real serverless alternative to it or buy Algolia or something...


Yes, I would be much happier that. I do not even understand why to do this whole dance with Elastic.


Same. But there is nothing preventing doing that and running a fork of Elastic, it's cheap enough.

I would do the same if I were AWS.


A lot of people have adopted the Elastic stack over the years, I guess Amazon just wanted their share.


They do. They've done similar things with Redis and MariaDB, both of whom also offer commercial solutions. The SAs all insist that "no it's a partnership". I don't fault them they're parroting the marketing line. With the new Grafana stuff that seems more like a real partnership because you have to purchase the enterprise features and support from the marketplace. What they've done to Redis and partiularly Elastic is pretty shameful.

The Elasticsearch Service has problems: you can't join the cluster like you can with the normal version, permissions are janky at best, it's slow, and it's expensive. For those reasons the projects my team used it on opted to roll our own elasticsearch cluster which proved a better solution long term beyond the initial annoyances. I say that to say it's not a one to one product, which will probably be their defense.


Sure thing. That's the reason for many services they created.

But they usually tend to build their own alternative that integrates better into their eco-system.


I think most people just wanted Amazon to take the administrative overhead away from them. Amazon saw that gap.



But not serverless.

If you create an index, you have to pay at least 2,50€ per hour it runs.

All pricing examples were multiple thousands of Euros per month.


Better in what ways?


In many ways. I could write a book about this but lets just say operational stability and reliability is the primary reasons.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: