Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It depends on what side of town you're on. There is a big class and culture gap in the US financial system. Everyone on this forum from the US likely is well banked. But a large chunk of the US is not. A large number of people either do not meet the requirements (undocumented immigrants), distrust the system, or don't meet minimum balance requirements (or don't want to deal with those requirements).

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/08/25percent-of-us-households-a...

https://www.npr.org/2021/04/05/984475870/unbanked-what-it-me...



I'm "well banked" I guess, but the laundromat nearest me still only takes quarters for some godforsaken reason and sometimes it is convenient for parking meters (although most of them use the same app nowadays).


Prepaid debit cards are now widely used by unbanked people in the US. Some employers will even do direct deposit to those cards.


This is true, but cash is still widely used by the unbanked as well. Go to a grocery store in a poor part of town and you will see plenty of cash being handled at the checkouts.


Minimum balance requirements? Why is that a thing?


Banks make money by lending on deposits. If you have no deposits, they can't make any money. Although, almost universally, banks will allow you to pay a few dollars per month for your account instead. But, people who don't have very much money usually don't have much of a need to spend spend money for a service to hold on to their money, because they don't have any.


But it still needs an explanation because European banks don't charge for a current account.


I don't think a few dollars here and there is not really indicative of a huge difference in anything but product/marketing strategies and consumer preferences. Banks have a lot of different fees that vary not only between continents, but between banks that literally sit across the street from each other.


I thought most European banks do charge for basic accounts?

"Free" accounts seems like a big US thing because there's lots of competition between a highly fractionated banking industry. Something like 4000 banks in USA and next biggest is Russia with ~400

https://www.helgilibrary.com/charts/what-country-has-the-mos...

Reviewing some traditional French banks and their "mobile" offerings are still 2EUR/month, and students can get a 1EUR/month plan.


Perhaps it's just UK and Norway then


There's lots of other differences.

For example historically and until fairly recently, most American banks were prohibited from having more than one branch. In total.

That's called unit banking. And that's why you have those small-town American banks, and national chains almost everywhere else.

Obviously, that bank with only one location is much more dependent on the fortunes of its only location. This makes for a hilariously brittle financial system.


So they can make money charging you fees when you go under the minimum? /S


No sarcasm needed, this is a big reason.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: