Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"Another comment, more on-topic: it may surprise some to learn that the ‘crane’ or ‘claw’ games in arcades and rest stops are also games of chance, not games of skill. They are programmed with the value of their prizes, the cost to play, and the operating margin the operator would like to have. The machine handles the decision of who wins, when."

It wouldn't surprise me a little bit if it was true, since it's almost impossible to get any prize using those cranes, but if it is in fact true, it should definitely be illegal. When I see a game in the style of these crane games, I and pretty much everyone believes it is a "game of skill", and if you just get the crane in the right position, it would be able to get your prize. Down here in Brazil those machines are everywhere.



I’m sure there are some ‘dumb’ machines out there but on p8 you can see the basics of how a ‘smart’ machine works [pdf]: https://www.betson.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/E-Claw-Ser...


It's all out there in the open if you know where to look, huh.


The claw strength is controlled in software. You can set the percentage of time it's actually strong enough to grip, and even the percentage of time it will lose its grip on an object it's already picked up.


It's true and it's not illegal. (at least in the US) Mark Rober did a couple videos on YouTube about arcade scams. (there are many) They are highly entertaining and depressing at the same time.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: