Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

While it seems clear that general vibe is trending to the negative, it's interesting to me that everyone has their own slant on it. My personal issue with Graham is that his writings are all trite common sense-isms dressed up as complicated analogies or profound insight. Like the way people claim Steve Jobs had a "reality distortion field", as if the term "charisma" wasn't coined for good reason a billion years ago...

I mean, at least Andreessen communicates directly, even if he's out of touch and tone deaf.

Anyway, we all have our gripes, and I think this article is poorly written, and the original article it links to is even worse. Doing no service to the fact that the people currently orbiting our little hovel of geekdom leave a lot to be desired. Or maybe you think this rant is poorly written and misses the mark...



> Like the way people claim Steve Jobs had a "reality distortion field", as if the term "charisma" wasn't coined for good reason

Back in the day that was called 'being charming', not 'charismatic', and it was an offense: you're being intentionally dishonest and manipulative. Now it just means it's cute. Language changes...


It must change a lot...when was being charming ever an offense?


It depends on the crowd.

Being charming to old school Germans means you’re a scam artist/unauthentic.

Most ‘greatest generation’ folks (if they’re still alive) had a similar feeling/overtone.

Because it’s true - someone being charming is making themselves likable to be liked (selling themselves), instead of letting their warts show. Because at a minimum they want your company. And it often works.

Someone being grumpy and unpleasant probably doesn’t give a shit, eh? And isn’t trying to sell you anything. In fact, chances are they’d be happier if you didn’t buy anything, and left them alone.

Which one is more likely to be a scam?


[flagged]


None of the people I’m noting are even aware of HN’s existence

It’s what happens when scammers run amok (like now) and they are the ones that have to clean up the mess.

We’ll get another generation like that soon.


> Like the way people claim Steve Jobs had a "reality distortion field", as if the term "charisma" wasn't coined for good reason a billion years ago...

Charisma is active - as in, the charismatic leader talks you into believing their bullshit. Reality distortion field is passive - as in, you hang out too much around the leader, or people hanging out around the leader, and you end up believing their bullshit.


If there’s a person on this planet what was never passive that person is Steve Jobs.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: