Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I also live in Chicago and wouldn’t mind walking extra to another stop, but Chicago also has a massive traffic problem, particularly post pandemic. During rush hour, the bus is stop and go already.

I’m really curious how this would pan out here, but it can’t be the only solution.



I think the only way to solve this is to invest much more into making buses nicer & increasing the numbers, and then instituting bus-only lanes on major arterial roads so that taking the bus becomes faster than fighting traffic.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Downs%E2%80%93Thomson_paradox asserts that the speed of cars is caused by the speed of public transit. Improving public transit reduces traffic jams, even if you take away car lanes to do it.


Chicago has already done all of those things unfortunately (or fortunately).


If they have bus-only lanes then they won't be stuck in traffic, so I don't think they have.


Bus only lanes exist, but not everywhere (some streets are not wide enough). Additionally, at the moment (and really always) there's a ton of construction on the bridges going in and out of the city, causing buses to miss out on the bus-only lanes for years or more at a time. Bus systems are a complicated beast.


You don't have to allow cars on every single paved surface. Cars aren't supposed to be on wide sidewalks, you don't have to allow them on every single road either.


I think I agree with you. Now the political will to make such a change on the other hand...


Oh yeah, "you" was the generic "you". Agree on this, I'm working on it slowly in my own town; it's all I can do.


Yeah if they aren't enforcing the bus-only aspect then it's not really a bus-only lane. If a bus only lane exists but people violate it in cars with impunity then obviously it's not going to work.


San Francisco put in some bus only lanes and those routes have greatly improved bus speed and ontime performance.


The traffic downtown is really nuts now that the bridges are all shut down.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: